I'm looking for a new rod and reel, and was wondering what the best 250 dollar combo is? I'm a new fly fisherman, so I don't know what the good rods and reels are. Any advice?
-- Edited by LilWhippersnapper at 19:57, 2007-02-06
In that price range I like the Sage entry level package. It's a Launch series rod, a 1201 reel, plus fly line and backing. It's a little more than you are looking to spend ($280 at http://www.flyfishingoutfitters.com/p/s/viewitem.aspx?pid=FFO-FRE-08IT-000), but if you shop around you might be able to find it for a little less.
I've fished this particular setup for more than a year now and have nothing but good things to say about it.
Kiene's sells a 199$ redington combo. Its alright, for that price range it would almost be cheaper to buy the reel and rod seperate, and put a line on at a seperate date. If you do that, go with the sage FI series, or a top of the line TFO or echo.
My first rod was a fenwick HMG 8'6" two peice fast action, and a cabelas large arbor reel, total cost was $300.00 with flyline and backing included, this outfit performs very well for me, cant say anything bad about it, its a nice looking rod and is made in the good ol usa, with lifetime no questions asked warranty. Good luck, choosing a rod and reel is alot of fun. Do your research and make an informed decision. Sage seems to be very very popular with everyone. I'dike to add that i agree 100% that the rod is were you do not scimp, then the line, then the reel. I really like rio lines.
Whatever reel you purchase, it may be a good idea to buy a reel that has been around a while so that you can purchase spare spools when you need them. Buying spare spools is a lot cheaper than buy a new reel. Reels that are new to the market or reels made by lesser known companies may not be around in a couple of years (when you might want to purchase a new spool).
When I bought my first fly set up, the guy recommended that I go nicer on the rod and maybe downgrade a little on the reel. For example: You got $500-600. Instead of buying a 300 dollar rod and a 200 dollar reel step and buy a better rod and a slightly less expensive reel. I am glad I did this because its cheaper to upgrade the reel over the rod.
As mentioned above It's worth it to get a rod with a lifetime warranty, last year I guillotined one in a power window and busted another while setting the hook in a 3lb rainbow (full disclosure I think the rod was damaged in a slip&fall the previous day that also broke my finger). I picked up both at an Orvis shop, the only question asked when I dropped them off for warranty was "and where would you like your new rod sent?". I'm happy with the rods, support and the convenience of a shop that is less than a mile from my house.
Definitely agree with the life time rods. More than worth it, and it pays for its self over the yrs. If your original rod was 400, you break it, cost is minimal. If you had gone with a 200 dollar rod without insurance, you buy a new one for another 200. As for the reels, being around awhile does not guarantee spools will be around, a lot of reels change slightly, so that the spools a re incompatible. Best bet is to pick up reel that has been around a while, and has not been modified or tweaked lately, or just pick up a spool or two on purchase.
Spend some time searching on ebay, there are some fantastic deals to be found. For example, I have picked up 2 Sage rods, an SLT 5wt and an XP 6wt. Both rods were brand new with blank warranty cards. I got the STL for $475, new they are $620. The XP new is $655, I got it for $430. They don't make the XP anymore since it was replaced by the Z-axis but the warranty is still good on it. A good solid mid level reel is a Teton/Tioga. There is a seller on ebay that has an ebay store and sells brand new reels and the prices can't be beat. You could get a nice Tioga #6 for around $100 when new they are $160 or so. Here is his link, I've purchased 5 reels from him:
http://stores.ebay.com/Fly-Reels-Deluxe
Spend more money now on a better rod, that's the way to go!
Try casting a few rods by Scott. Their new rods are amazing, I want a G2 sooooo bad! But try casting a V2 if you like med. action, or a A2 if you want a little faster...The A2 is a little above your price range though.
I own a Scott. They're really nice rods. I actually picked mine up at a clearance sale a couple of years ago. The last couple of rods that I've bought were in the fall when most shops are trying to clear things out.
__________________
"Nothing makes a fish bigger than almost being caught."
JT wrote: I own a Scott. They're really nice rods. I actually picked mine up at a clearance sale a couple of years ago. The last couple of rods that I've bought were in the fall when most shops are trying to clear things out.