Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Flows


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 584
Date:
Flows
Permalink  
 


Am I the only one thats concerned about the flows ? Why do they drop the flows to 67 cfs durring the time when eggs are in the graval and cant move to flowing water ??  I dont get it ?. I for one am mad .  Doesnt the wild trout desegnation help with issues like flow drops . I think what make me so mad I have a hard time saying what I want is I dont spell very well and cant say what really think 

is anyone paying attention ??? 



__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 13
Date:
Permalink  
 

I think current flows are consistent with historical data



__________________
Kevin Scully


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 463
Date:
Permalink  
 

You must be mad all the time

__________________


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 55
Date:
Permalink  
 

The fishery is not suffering and is actually thriving. Just relax.

__________________
Ty


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 291
Date:
Permalink  
 

If you wanna get mad, search #putahcreek on instagram.  You'll see whats been going on this winter.



__________________


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 463
Date:
Permalink  
 

God I wish you didn't post that. Some guy even filmed himself targeting spawners. That place just needs to be closed to fishing during the winter.

__________________
Ty


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 291
Date:
Permalink  
 

I know what you mean Ross.  Can't un-see that.



__________________


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 205
Date:
Permalink  
 

I looked too, wish I didn't

__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 14
Date:
Permalink  
 

lol,

Those images are both pathetic and hilarious. Why? Because those posters (poachers) genuinely feel they achieved something to be proud of. They feel no shame in posting pics of females squirting eggs in an act of desperation before looming death.

With such a big push to get Putah "blue ribbon" status, and with the creek most accessible during the winter, a winter closure seems far off...so long as the primary interest resides in $450 guided trips, prestige, and fishermen who have been led to believe impale, torture, repeat is a harmless practice...

...don't toss a treble, but redd raping with a fly is "acceptable"...so long as you don't harvest your catch...

__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 6
Date:
Permalink  
 

I was able to get in touch with that younger guy a couple weeks ago to let him know the importance of not fishing in that area and mainly the whole creek during winter time and why. He seemed to genuinely understand and said that it was a spot his father showed him and as a beginner he didn't really know any better. I know a lot of us have heard some version of that story but he agreed to show the fish some more respect in the future. Doesn't make up for anything but hopefully it will in the future. I'm all for a winter closure. In the meantime the people who care need to keep educating others who don't or don't know any better. And don't be afraid to call caltip.

__________________

-Clayton 

Ty


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 291
Date:
Permalink  
 

Being the one who mentioned the instagram thing, It only seems right to say that I was guilty of doing the same thing on the redds.  It was my first time fly fishing, at Putah late November 5 or 6 years ago.  Me and a friend were at a spot watching other guys fish, trying to learn a thing or two.  One guy comes up and asks if we were going to fish right where we were standing and we said no, (we wanted to watch and learn).  He proceeded to pull a few big rainbows out and release them in about 5 minutes.  We were in awe of the fish, and this guy.  He split right away and left us to fish that same spot which later, months later, we realized was a redd and those were spawners we were targeting. 

Trying to make a long story short, ya some people really don't have a clue.  I don't recall seeing all the signs around the access spots back then.   I went on this board and was educated on the ethics and the spawn and how to be a responsible angler.  We should all try and educate when we can, and be open to keep learning.

 

 



__________________


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 205
Date:
Permalink  
 

I think we are guilty of it but that is due to ignorance more then being unethical. Once we had an understanding of what we were doing we stopped.

In regards to the guide reference in the above post, I do the majority of the guiding on the creek and do not touch it from December to March. This hurts the pocket book but the fishery is more important to me then the making money. I have a major problem with any guide who does any guiding on the creek this time of year.

__________________


Veteran Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 38
Date:
Permalink  
 

You know what--I have read this thread and it is just really un-becoming all the judgement and mudslinging going on! We all fly-fish because of the beauty, the mystery, the challenge, the obsession of hooking a fish on a fly--- some people make their living doing that and some do it for fun only. And guess what else? Trout have been spawning and breeding in Putah and all those thousands or rivers for millions of years......they AREN'T threatened because people fish the creek in the Winter; they ARE threatened because of Poachers, Pollution, Pesticides, Fertilizers, lack of spawning habitat due to human-related issues, and because we have built dams which make reservoirs and "kill" normal rivers, and many other factors which I don't have the ability to speak to. 

This forum was created to create a COMMUNITY of Fly-Fishers; and threads like these when people start calling people names, judging others who they have no right to judge, and more mudslinging are just hurtful to everyone and to the sport we all love. Let this be the END of this thread and the END of the mudslinging. It's really not cool. Enough.



__________________

"You are my treasure and my reward
Let nothing ever come before
You are my treasure and my reward
Let nothing ever come before
I seek You
First" 

-Lauren Daigle



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 730
Date:
Permalink  
 

chuckle

__________________

Winter eats heat the way darkness swallows light. The terrors of failed power and frozen stems are stymied with fire, smoke and white ash.

Cedarville, Mi



Administrator

Status: Offline
Posts: 306
Date:
Permalink  
 

Prettyfly,

 

A voice of reason. Thank you. 

That being said, IMHO knowingly targeting spawning trout on the PC is really disrespectful to the trout and all of the people who put hard work into recovering this gem. It's selfish. 

 

I do do think that fishing away from the beds is kosher  - just not terribly productive anyway during this time.  I figure, why even bother. There are other waters that more productive. I also think that PC benefits from the presence of enlightened fisherman/ nature lovers during this time that can keep the miscreants at bay.

 

Dan



-- Edited by drdan on Monday 26th of January 2015 08:15:40 PM

__________________

Support Putah Creek Trout in their mission to improve the wild trophy trout fishery. Visit and contribute at https://putahcreektrout.org



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 463
Date:
Permalink  
 

👆 Exactly what I was thinking

__________________


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 730
Date:
Permalink  
 

Why the chuckle:

For a forum on the internet, there is very very little "mud-slinging" in here.  Keith runs a pretty tight ship, we don't always see eye to eye but I can respect him for what he does.  I'm also pretty sure Greg started this site to promote his business, not sing kumbaya with other people that like to flyfish.

Monticello dam was built between 1953 and 1957.  I might be wrong but if my old man memory serves me right, prior to the dam being built, Putah creek was similar to Cache creek and not exactly a trout paradise.  Monticello dam transformed Putah creek into the fishery we all know today.  The 50's just weren't millions of years ago.

The oddity is that Monticello created this fishery, while other dams are blamed for the decline of fisheries.  Imagine hooking steelhead or salmon (ick)  on the upper Sac, McCloud or Pit rivers.  Think of all the spawning habitat there or above Engelbright and Bullards Bar.  Columbia river!  The point being that Monticello did not "kill' Putah.

So the woes of Putah?  Poachers--yup, Pollution, pesticides and fertalizers--I doubt it.  Nobody likes looking at garbage in and around the areas they fish and Putah is no different.  Short of illegal dumping of leaking car batteries and ag chemicals were not looking at major fish die-offs.  Lack of spawning habitat, ding ding ding.

I'm sure somebody at UCD or with F & W have looked at the long term ecology of Putah.  It would be interesting to see the info but it's probably buried in archives somewhere or found in old scientific journals.  I just can't believe that there haven't been at least a few grad studies done considering the proximity to Davis.  Ah, but let's digress back to lack of spawning habitat.

Sarah, you mentioned "lack of spawning habitat due to human-related issues".  I'd guess the biggest culprit would likely be sedimentation.  Invasive species such as NZMS and I imagine certain types of plants probably also play some sort of a role.  I majored in wildlife management and not fisheries so I probably fail to get the full gist of stream dynamics.  It seems like some sedimentation would be a good thing for vegetation, hence bugs and ultimately fish and other critters, but with most things in life, too much of a good thing isn't always a good thing.

Putah hasn't had a major water event in some time, mid to late 90's I think but there may have been a high water year in the early 2000's?   When water 8+ feet deep is blasting over the glory hole the creek receives a pretty good scouring.  Granted, all that muck probably just settles in the slow sections and ultimately above Diversion dam.  Displace the sediment and associated vegetation and you end up with spawning habitat.  Is a high rain year that tops the Glory hole enough, I don't know.  I do know that the creeks above the bridge pump out a ton of sedimentation into Putah.  It's understandable on the creek North of Putah as it's semi barren grassland used for cattle.  The south side has lots of vegetation so for grins n giggles I'll blame it on all the day hikers.

The lack of spawning habitat prompted the grass/weed abatement efforts which started a couple of years ago.  The good news is that the weed abatement worked, the bad news is the weed abatement worked.  That work made it even easier for people to target some really nice sized fish which were now stacked up in those locations.  Yes people poach them and otherwise legitimate fishermen target them.  I've talked to the same people on multiple occasions 2 years in a row about fishing on redds and targeting spawning fish.  I have little doubt they were back up there again this season.  They know exactly what they are doing and just don't care.  Sure, some people see the light but many just don't care.  I believe it takes very few of the poachers or fishermen that don't care to make a huge impact.

Education, in my opinion, just doesn't work as I would hope.  Perhaps over time, but repeat offenders of those targeting spawning fish leads me to believe otherwise.  The majority of the rivers in this state close down in the Winter.  I would assume it is in some shape, fashion or form, an attempt to preserve the fisheries.  Putah, as we know, does not have that regulation.  Low water flows, large and congregated fish that are often very visible and easily targeted, don't bode well to sportsmanship with individuals that don't care.

So close Putah in the Winter?  Ah, Pandora's box.  Jordan stays off the creek from December to March, but when exactly is the spawn?  At what date do we regulate the end of the season and at what time do we deem the creek fishable again in the spring?  I've seen fish spawning in October through January.  How long after the last of the spawn before the fry are out of the gravel?  A rough guess would be a month from fertilization to hatching and another couple of weeks from alevin to fry.  So shut down the creek from the end of September to the end of March?  6 MONTHS?  I'm sure others have dates in mind but that would be an argument one would have to present to the F&W commission.

Pandora's box

 



__________________

Winter eats heat the way darkness swallows light. The terrors of failed power and frozen stems are stymied with fire, smoke and white ash.

Cedarville, Mi



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 987
Date:
Permalink  
 

Robert et al, there is nothing like succes to fully open the PC version of Pandora's box. In 2009, after the cessation of hatchery fish planting in the face of a five fish limit, the creek really was not worth fishing for most people. Five years later we now have a healthy fishery, but one that is under attack by some individuals with whatever reasons for taking and keeping fish or targeting the spawners that from year to year are a major key to maintaining the health of the fishery.

In following this thread, I see the "choir preaching to the choir" element in your comments about redd fishing, which is a good thing, but I don't see suggestions for preventative action, other than closing the Creek, that can actively be pursued in an organized way for the short-term. I.e., what can we, as stewards of the Creek, do in a concerted and focused project, to reduce the amount of spawner harassment? Speaking for PCT, I'm wide open to suggestions.

IMO, poaching of the large fish that are our brood stock during the spawning season is the biggest threat to the fishery. These fish are surely being pulled off the redds by poachers, based on 3rd party info I have received. I think Richard has the right idea, that is, surveillance, but it needs to be done in a manner that is safe and within the law.

I know many are willing to volunteer, but are waiting for guidance and leadership. Now that Wild Trout designation has been achieved, PCT will turn its focus to addressing problems that may be having a negative impact on the Creek and fishery



__________________

PCT Contact Info: putahcreektrout@gmail.com, SK60@putahcreektrout.org

Address: Putah Creek Trout, 1520 East  Covell Blvd, Suite 5, #331, Davis CA 95616

Visit our website at www.putahcreektrout.org



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 730
Date:
Permalink  
 

Thanks for chiming in Steve. Let's expand on Richards idea but note I'm on a phone so this will be brief (crowd applauds). ;)

Taking a picture of a white ford on the side of the road does nothing. Taking a video of illegal activity might. Granted, observations of actual "poaching" on the creek is probably pretty rare unless on is actively looking for said activity.

Anything in the F & W code regarding fair chase, ethical us of resource etc?
Could language be proposed to the commission for such?
I'm thinking of intentional sight fishing on redds.

Again, Richards idea on patrols, educate when possible, video document when it fails or contact is a concern for safety. Talk with F & W warden on what will/can stick in court.

A hit to the wallet talks. It will also piss a lot of people off, not that I really care. Guy quit driving through the creek with his jeep right.

Signs indicating patrols during spawn with violations being documented and Perseus for prosecution.

Word WILL get out

__________________

Winter eats heat the way darkness swallows light. The terrors of failed power and frozen stems are stymied with fire, smoke and white ash.

Cedarville, Mi



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 463
Date:
Permalink  
 

SK60 maybe planting bushes or trees along the bank to help deter people fishing spawners. I know people will try and find a way around or through BUT it'll who don't wanna try hard to pursue fish (they target spawners can't get more lazy than that). Some natural growing plants like those black berry bushes.

__________________


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 730
Date:
Permalink  
 

Good idea and points. BB bushes are the devil though. Spawning bed habitat work in areas "out of the way"?

__________________

Winter eats heat the way darkness swallows light. The terrors of failed power and frozen stems are stymied with fire, smoke and white ash.

Cedarville, Mi



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 730
Date:
Permalink  
 

Cause the deterioration or waste of any fish taken in the waters of this state ( Section 1.87)??? Really stretching and grasping at straws.

Low flow restrictions such as those found on the Mad, Mattole, Smith Rivers or Redwood creek and a large number of other streams???  Yes I realize it's still closure based but not "specified" as the spawn.

I saw nothing else in the regs hmm

 

 

 



__________________

Winter eats heat the way darkness swallows light. The terrors of failed power and frozen stems are stymied with fire, smoke and white ash.

Cedarville, Mi



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 987
Date:
Permalink  
 

Just a couple of comments for now. Robert, you have hit on several positive actions that, if vetted with DFW and OK, could be explored. What I have heard about license plates is that enforcement will access Cal-tips DB and check their list for prior reports on a vehicle and at least our local warden appreciates that effort on our part. And real time calls to CAl-tip resulted in rapid follow up on more than one occasion. The problem is that "rapid" depends whose in the area to respond. Last fall we had two wardens drive over from Rio Vista (took at least 30 minutes) and by then the perp had gotten nervous and split. They then patrolled the creek for a while before heading back. The key here was that Richard drove to the resort and called Cal-tip immediately The second key is, if you show you care by making that effort, you get attention paid (greased squeaky wheel syndrome). More you call, more response.

Within the constraints of the law and safe practices, we have to apply pressure on the the snaggers-it has got to be stopped-and that hasn't a chance to succeed unless we apply the pressure by being vigilant and the eyes for enforcement.

A comment on DFW resources: the enforcement division in the Sacramento area is recruiting for applicants to fill natural resource volunteer positions in the department. The person I spoke to said personnel resources are so limited they need volunteers to provide staff support in biological, enforcement, and administrative activities. Maybe the wardens will be able to spend more effort in the field.



__________________

PCT Contact Info: putahcreektrout@gmail.com, SK60@putahcreektrout.org

Address: Putah Creek Trout, 1520 East  Covell Blvd, Suite 5, #331, Davis CA 95616

Visit our website at www.putahcreektrout.org



Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 463
Date:
Permalink  
 

Low flow restrictions would be best. It's not a permanent fall/winter closure but will keep the option of visitors coming into winters for business. Like a 140 CFS or lower closure would be ideal.



-- Edited by Rossflyguy on Wednesday 28th of January 2015 05:39:06 PM

__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 9
Date:
Permalink  
 

Not to bang on wardens because I am well aware of the low numbers but if the poaching issue is so dismal, why isn't patrolling during this time of year more of a priority for wardens? I do not live in Solano county so I cannot speak on what the other more important priorities are for F&W. There is a lot to balance in terms of enforcement-waterfowl season, pig hunting, etc. but for the prestige and hard work that has gone into the creek, it would make sense to at least during this time of year have a more significant presence. Volunteers are good but without law enforcement powers you can't do much with the flagrant violators except put yourself in a potentially dangerous situation. Be safe out there!


__________________


Master Fly Fishing Guide

Status: Offline
Posts: 531
Date:
Permalink  
 

Wow lots of dialogue on this topic as usual, so I will make this  brief. I am entirely behind a creek closure and have not guided the creek during the spawning period from Dec 1  through March 1. In the past I have not fished the known spawning areas but still caught  spawning fish, thats when I called it  quits which was 3 years ago and from that point on a lot of other anglers and guides followed suit. This forum was a big part of that as well. I still get a lot of calls and emails about fishing the creek this time of year and so far everyone that I spoke with had not a clue about the plight of  the spawners and completely support staying away during that period. One thing that I have noticed is over the last few years the crowds of years ago during the winter  months is nowhere near as bad as it used to be. Hopefully this is and trend  that will continue we just have to keep getting the word out.



__________________
Greg Bonovich
greg@putahcreekflyfishing.com
http://www.putahcreekflyfishing.com
Phone: 800-480-5285
Cell: 707-480-3809


Senior Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 987
Date:
Permalink  
 

Its not up to the wardens; its up to those that benefit from this resource to be the eyes and ears for them and report to them whats going on. I am going to be on a perpetual soapbox on this. Call CAL-Tip or use Keith's "report suspicious activity" form-the one with the big stop sign on the tab on the home page, or post here on the forum--take five minutes and just do it!!! Enough reports, the wardens will be on PC more often. 



-- Edited by SK60 on Saturday 7th of February 2015 04:23:09 PM



-- Edited by SK60 on Saturday 7th of February 2015 04:23:51 PM

__________________

PCT Contact Info: putahcreektrout@gmail.com, SK60@putahcreektrout.org

Address: Putah Creek Trout, 1520 East  Covell Blvd, Suite 5, #331, Davis CA 95616

Visit our website at www.putahcreektrout.org

Page 1 of 1  sorted by
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.



Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard